I didn’t really love my husband when we got married. He didn’t love me either.
Can you fall in love with someone you have never met? Really, truly, in LOVE? In the age of internet dating, chat rooms, email, can you cultivate deep, committed love, without being together?
I don’t think so.
Rick and I met for the first time on top of the Empire State Building. It was just like that movie, Sleepless in Seattle. I had imagined myself like Meg Ryan, arriving breathless, flopping her wallet open to buy a ticket, and moments later, stepping out on top of the world to meet the love of her life. They were MFEO. (Made for each other.)
With a few minor changes, that is how it happened for us.
I got lost walking to the Chrysler Building instead of the Empire State Building. In a New York August heat wave… 90% humidity, 102 degrees. I finally arrived looking like KISS with a sunburn and bloody blistered feet. I was two hours late, and then waited in a 90 minute line in the basement of the building to buy my ticket. Other than that, it was super romantic. We fell into each other’s arms. People took our picture, and clapped. We held hands, he kissed me softly after we gazed out into the night cityscape, dazzled by the enormous city.
Our lives together began.
Rick had just been released from a two-year mormon mission in Sacramento, CA. He had flown home after his two years of service to Vermont, where he had kissed his mother, barbecued with his father, and greeted his sister with his new niece for the first time. He also planned this trip to NYC. To meet me, a stranger, and the woman he loved. Rick had met my brother, a fellow LDS missionary in Sacramento, when they had been assigned as roommates. Zack was just six months into his two-year commitment, and Rick was one year into his. Like most other missionaries…he was busy, focused, homesick, and trolling for mail. Contact with people from the outside, the real world, was crucial.
The mission rules were strict, and contact with family and friends was only allowed through the USPS. No phone calls, no email, no text messages. Rick saw a picture of me, among my brother’s things, and casually asked if I was his girlfriend. Horrified, as any little brother would be, he informed Elder Poulin of our sibling relationship. (Elder is the assigned title men in the mission field use. It is a recognition of the spiritual power they are given. Women are not allowed to have this power, and are referred to as “sisters.”)
A week later, Elder Poulin sent out a letter. To me.
A little desperate? Yep.
But in reality, I had been desperate too. Not for a mormon missionary. At that time in my life, a missionary was dead last on my list of desires, but for some inexplicable reason, I wrote him back. Perhaps it was a mercy letter. I hated to be rude, or hurt his feelings. Perhaps I was desperately alone and jumping at the chance to express my innermost fears to a person I was not invested in. Perhaps I somehow knew that he would offer me healing in a way I could not find on my own.
What ever the reason, it worked. Elder Poulin won the snail mail jack pot. In the 395 days that ensued, we wrote over 150 letters. A few months in, we began carrying mini cassette recorders everywhere we went, conspicuously talking to each other in long, drawn out conversations that took two weeks to complete. 7, 425 minutes of conversation, to be precise. At first, a casual way to insert a bit of excitement into a week of monotony. Who doesn’t love to get a letter…hand written…in the mail?
It grew from casual fun, to inexplicable, illegal attraction, infatuation…love?
Missionaries were supposed to be dedicated only to God. Elder Poulin and I were not to write of things involving love and lust, so we wrote of ourselves, shared our fears and hopes, mailed pictures of ourselves in hopes of familiarizing the hopelessly unfamiliar.
Can you love someone you have never met?
The question ran through my mind on endless repeat for more than a year. It defined my life and decisions I made as a young college grad.
We were engaged one month after we met, and married four months later. Madly in love, or so we thought. We were ready for the Happily Ever After part.
Today, we have been married for 12 years. We have moved across the country and back again. Welcomed three beautiful little girls into our family. We have left the mormon religion, and are still healing from the aftermath of stepping off of our foundation of faith.
Here’s what we discovered about love:
You can’t truly love someone you have not met.
Which means, I don’t believe that Rick and I loved each other as much as we thought we did when we became man and wife. We had been with each other for less than six months. It’s not enough time. It was an arranged marriage. Each of us exchanging parts of a resume. We presented to each other our truest selves, on paper. In one-sided conversations, in which both of us listened and imagined being with that person, hand in hand. But something falls flat.
I loved that Rick was smart and open to adventure. He was athletic and physically active. He had a college degree, and ambition. He wanted to marry and have children, be an active father and role model. He was willing to show vulnerability, and he was a leader. He and I both wanted the same kind of life. We had the same interests, the same priorities. He was willing to work with me and my struggles of faith. He had strong, muscular hockey-player legs, dark wavy hair, a strong jaw, and an amazing ass. (Not that I was allowed to be looking). I still love all of these things about him.
What I didn’t know, was how he would look at me when I throw frustration fueled temper tantrum. If he would make me feel safe when I was scared. I didn’t know what Rick would when he felt threatened. I wasn’t sure if he would give me the space I needed to cool off when my feelings were hurt, or if he could be cruel and let biting words leave permanent scars in a fight. Would he let ego or fear of appearing weak, drive his decisions? Would he use his gender as a weapon, insist he had the final word? I couldn’t tell if he would be able to look through the letters, the pictures, the tapes, and see me.
Really, and truly see me.
The answers to these questions are needed to give dimension to real love. They only come with experiences life gives you as it unfolds over time. More than months, spent in a flurry of wedding planning and job hunting and moving.
We came together knowing so much about each other… so many questions answered, so many topics explored. But we were missing so much, the breath that brings the relationship to life. I have so often wondered, was it luck? Or are we such a good match because of the soul baring resumes we created in those 150 letters? The naive faith I placed in our ability to fill in all of the cracks… fissures I could not see or anticipate in my young twenty-three years… was that real intuition, or just blind luck?
Maybe it’s both.
Our courtship, engagement, and marriage has been a study in romance vs. reality.
You can not love someone you have never met.
Not a full, living, breathing, multidimensional love that can carry you through the joys and the gauntlets life lays out for you. We did not marry with that love, but it came to life for us in the small moments that create memories, history, trust.
I remember the first time Elder Poulin signed a letter, “Love, Rick.” And my heart cart-wheeled in my chest.
I remember the first time I admitted to Rick, whispering into my mini cassette tape, curled up in bed, that I was falling in love.
I remember feeling him grab me in the throng of tourists on top of the Empire State Building, and the thrill of believing I had just met my soul mate.
I remember watching a tear roll down his cheek when Fantine dies in broadway’s Les Miserables… how that tear cracked me open.
I remember spying on him as he bathed our daughters since they were a few days old, singing Peter, Paul and Mary’s Marvelous Toy, kissing their toes.
I remember how he would take their hands as toddlers and skip down the sidewalk with them like Dorothy in the wizard of Oz, unconcerned with anything but their thrilled giggles.
I remember the first moment I felt completely safe… when I knew without a doubt that we had survived leaving the mormon church, and he loved the real me.
I remember the moment I looked directly into his eyes as I was overcome with exhaustion and fear while trying to birth my last baby girl. I saw the real, breathing, luminous love for me in his eyes, and she was born.
I remember when someone asked me to conjure up an image in my mind of safety, a representation of the thing that would make me feel completely protected…
That image is me, in Rick’s arms.
There is no other place.